Skip to main content

Table 2 Model training and validation for the 24 included studies

From: Artificial intelligence performance in detecting lymphoma from medical imaging: a systematic review and meta-analysis

First author and year

Target condition

Reference standard

Type of internal validation

External validation

Zhou Z, 2021

MCL

Histopathology

Five-fold cross validation

Yes

McAvoy M, 2021

PCNSL

Histopathology

NR

No

Li D, 2020

DLBCL

Histopathology

NR

No

Miyoshi H, 2020

DLBCL, FL

Histopathology or expert consensus

Five-fold cross-validation

No

Park JE, 2020

Lymphoma

Histopathology

NR

Yes

Mohlman JS, 2020

BL, DLBCL

Histopathology

Leave-one-out cross-validation

No

Achi HE, 2019

DLBCL, BL, SLL

Histopathology

NR

No

Im H, 2018

Lymphoma

Histopathology

Random split-sample validation

No

Guan Q, 2019

NHL

Histopathology

NR

No

Guo R, 2021

ENKTL

Histopathology

NR

No

Xia W, 2021

PCNSL

Histopathology

Five-fold cross validation

No

Zhang Y, 2021

PCNSL

Histopathology

NR

No

Syrykh C, 2020

FL

Histopathology

NR

Yes

Wang H, 2020

ENKTL

Histopathology

Ten-fold cross-validation

No

Zhang J, 2020

NHL

NR

Five-fold cross validation

No

Wang Q, 2017

ALL

Histopathology

Cross validation

No

Schouten JPE, 2021

ALL

Expert consensus

Tenfold cross-validation

No

Nakagawa M, 2018

PCNSL

Expert consensus

Ten-fold cross-validation

No

Shafique S, 2018

ALL

Expert consensus

NR

No

Kong Z, 2019

PCNSL

Histopathology

Five-fold cross validation

No

Weisman AJ, 2020

Lymphoma

Expert consensus

Five-fold cross validation

No

Kim Y, 2018

PCNSL

Histopathology

Ten-fold cross-validation

Yes

Styczeń M, 2012

Splenic and gastric marginal zone lymphoma

Histopathology

NR

No

Guo J, 2018

OAL

Histopathology

NR

No

Azamossadat H, 2023

B-ALL

Histopathology

NR

No

Chava P, 2023

DLBCL, HGL

Histopathology

NR

Yes

Jermphiphut J, 2023

PCNSL

Histopathology

NR

No

Hikaru A, 2023

DLBCL

Histopathology

Five-fold cross-validation

No

Manjit K, 2023

ALL

Histopathology

NR

No

Noriaki H, 2023

DLBCL, FL and RL

Histopathology

Five-fold cross-validation

Yes

  1. NR not reported, MCL mantle cell lymphoma, PCNSL primary central nervous system lymphoma, DLBCL diffuse large B-cell lymphoma, HGL high grade lymphomas, FL follicular lymphoma, BL burkitt lymphoma, SLL small lymphocytic lymphoma, ENKTL nasal-type extranodal natural killer/T cell lymphoma, NHL non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma, ALL acute lymphoblastic leukemia, OAL ocular adnexal lymphoma, RL reactive lymphoid hyperplasia